A cozy tea setting with a tiered tray of pastries, teapots, teacups, and plates on a wooden table, surrounded by vintage furniture, blankets, and warm decorations in a softly lit room.
A simple brown fleur-de-lis symbol on a light gray background.

Afternoon Tea Menu for November

Join us for our “Tale of a Narnian Teatime” afternoon tea menu theme this fall.

Served Tuesday, November 4th – Sunday, November 30th, 2025.

By reservation only.

Ornate, symmetrical divider with loops and swirls in light brown, featuring small circular accents at each end, used for decorative separation in documents or invitations.
Cozy living room with vintage decor, an armchair, a tea set, and a tiered tray of pastries and sweets on a wooden coffee table. Dried flowers decorate the table, with a fireplace and blanket in the background.
Text in a decorative font reads: “The Tale of a Narnian Teatime.” Black letters on a white background.

Served November 4th – 30th, 2025

Regular Adult Menu includes one of each item listed below.

Menu and teas subject to change without notice.

Savories

served with "Pomander Orange Chai" traditional black tea

Three small white dishes with a wild rice and vegetable mix sit on a wooden surface, surrounded by a circular wreath of multicolored autumn leaves.
Magical Wild Rice with Butternut Squash
A blue and white teacup filled with tea sits beside a matching plate holding three small pastries. The setup rests on a plaid cloth near frosted evergreen branches with red berries.
The Pevensies’ Cottage Pie
A decorative sword lies beside a golden leaf-shaped plate holding three crackers topped with a creamy herb spread and chives, surrounded by autumn leaves on a script-patterned cloth.
Centaurs’ Cake of Oaten Meal
A plate with three rectangular tea sandwiches sits on a table outdoors, decorated with autumn leaves. A bronze lion statue stands in the grassy background.
Aslan’s Turkey Sandwich with Onion Marmalade
A plate with three triangular green-topped sandwiches sits on a red cloth, near a gift-wrapped box, under an outdoor lantern surrounded by glowing tree lights.
Mr. Tumnus’ Tea Sandwich with Chèvre & Fig Jam

Breads

served with "Caramel Delights" black tea

A gold leaf tray holds six biscuits with small bowls of cream and lemon curd, set on a faux fur tablecloth. Nearby are a silver teapot and a gold dish with brown sugar cubes.
St. James Traditional Cream Scone served with Clotted Cream and Lemon Curd
A rustic outdoor tea setting with a green teapot, two cups of tea, orange slices, muffins on wooden trays, a jar of marmalade, and sunflowers, surrounded by leafy greenery.
Mrs. Beaver’s Gloriously Sticky Orange Marmalade Roll

Sweets

served with "Spice Caravan" herbal tea

Three small pavlova desserts topped with cream and cherry preserves are arranged on a white plate with a lace doily. Decorative white napkins and soft, snowy elements surround the plate.
The White Witch’s Cranberry Pavlova
Three small glass cups of ice cream, each topped with a leaf-shaped cookie, are arranged on a wooden tray. A decorative acorn and patterned fabric sit nearby on a lace-covered table.
Chai Custard Ice Cream with a Chocolate Spice Cookie
Three chocolate desserts with white icing on a lacy plate, surrounded by snowflakes, pine branches, silver beads, and a silver deer figurine, evoking a festive winter theme.
Chocolate Cheesecake Enchantment

Regular Adult Menu includes one of each item listed above.

Menu and teas subject to change without notice.

Herbal Tea Options:
My Darling Clementine, Holiday Spice, Spice Caravan

The Tale of a Narnian Teatime Afternoon Tea Menu Variations

Brown decorative horizontal divider with symmetrical flourishes and loops in the center, ending with small circles on each side, against a light background.

Adult Menu

Savories

served with "Pomander Orange Chai" traditional black tea

Aslan’s Turkey Sandwich with Onion Marmalade
Centaurs’ Cake of Oaten Meal
The Pevensies’ Cottage Pie
Magical Wild Rice with Butternut Squash

Mr. Tumnus’ Traditional Tea Sandwich:
Cucumber, Fig, and Chèvre

 

Breads

served with "Caramel Delights" scented black tea

Mrs. Beaver’s Gloriously Sticky Orange Marmalade Roll
St. James Traditional Cream Scone
Lemon Curd & Clotted Cream

 

Sweets

served with "Spice Caravan" herbal tea

Chocolate Cheesecake Enchantment
The White Witch’s Cranberry Pavlova
Chai Custard Ice Cream with Chocolate Spice Cookie

Regular Adult Menu includes one of each item listed above.

Menu and teas subject to change without notice.

Featured Teas for Herbal Option:
"My Darling Clementine," "Holiday Spice," "Spice Caravan"

Vegetarian Menu

Savories

served with "Pomander Orange Chai" traditional black tea

Aslan’s Munster Cheese Sandwich with Onion Marmalade *
Centaurs’ Cake of Oaten Meal
The Pevensies’ Lentil Cottage Pie *
Magical Wild Rice with Butternut Squash

Mr. Tumnus’ Traditional Tea Sandwich:
Cucumber, Fig, and Chèvre

 

Breads

served with "Caramel Delights" scented black tea

Mrs. Beaver’s Gloriously Sticky Orange Marmalade Roll *
St. James Traditional Cream Scone *
Lemon Curd & Clotted Cream *

 

Sweets

served with "Spice Caravan" herbal tea

Chocolate Cheesecake Enchantment
The White Witch’s Cranberry Pavlova *
Chai Custard Ice Cream with Chocolate Spice Cookie *

Regular Vegetarian Adult Menu includes one of each item listed above.

Menu and teas subject to change without notice.

Featured Teas for Vegetarian Herbal Option:
"My Darling Clementine," "Holiday Spice," "Spice Caravan"

* Indicates Child Vegetarian Item

Children's Menu

Savories

served with "My Darling Clementine" herbal tea

Aslan’s Turkey Sandwich with Onion Marmalade
The Pevensies’ Cottage Pie

 

Breads

served with "Holiday Spice" herbal rooibos tea

Mrs. Beaver’s Gloriously Sticky Orange Marmalade Roll
St. James Traditional Cream Scone
Lemon Curd & Clotted Cream

 

Sweets

served with "Spice Caravan" herbal tea

The White Witch’s Cranberry Pavlova
Chai Custard Ice Cream with Chocolate Spice Cookie

Regular Child Menu includes one of each item listed above.

Menu and teas subject to change without notice.

Gluten Free Menu

We dare you to tell the difference between our Gluten Free and Gluten Full food!

Beautiful & Delicious

At The St. James Tearoom, we are proud to serve our entire menu in gluten-free form. Each recipe on our menu is translated into a gluten-free version that maintains the flavorful and unique character of each sumptuous morsel. It is important to us to bring you the best-tasting gluten-free menu that we can, for every menu theme of the year. We have seen tears of joy in our guests’ eyes when they realize they can enjoy a full teatime that’s gluten-free. It means a lot to so many, and so it means a lot to us.

A full teatime just for you!

Your gluten-free menu will be served on its own three-tiered tray, presented and tasting just as lovely as our regular menu. Regardless of what the other guests at the table have ordered for their meal (regular menu, vegetarian menu, etc.), you can still have the gluten-free menu that you need, kept separate from the other gluten food. Are you the guest of honor? The St. James Tearoom is the perfect place to celebrate with the most delicious gluten-free menu in town!

For those of our guests with extreme health issues related to gluten, please note that our gluten-free menu is still prepared in a kitchen where gluten is in use. If you have questions or concerns, please call us at (505) 242-3752.

Dietary Restrictions / Ingredients

Ornate, symmetrical divider with loops and swirls in light brown, featuring small circular accents at each end, used for decorative separation in documents or invitations.

Information About Our Food

Below is a basic ingredient list for the menu on this page. This is not a complete list but a list of ingredients most likely to affect allergies. Due to the complicated nature of guest allergies and dietary restrictions, and the excess labor involved, The St. James Tearoom cannot make any menu substitutions or changes. No exceptions.

Ingredients of Common Allergies:

Roast Turkey Sandwich with Onion Marmalade
wheat, turkey, bacon, avocado, mayonnaise, onion, olive oil, balsamic vinegar, seasoning
Vegetarian: Munster cheese replaces turkey and bacon

Cakes of Oaten Meal
wheat, dairy, blue cheese, oats, honey, white wine (reduced), chives, herbs, seasoning

Cottage Pie
wheat, dairy, eggs, Italian sausage, onions, garlic, Tabasco, potatoes, butternut squash, maple syrup, seasoning
Vegetarian: wheat, dairy, eggs, lentils, olive oil, onions, garlic, fennel, seasoning

Wild Rice with Butternut Squash
dairy, wild rice blend, butternut squash, leeks, olive oil, parsley, seasoning

Fig & Goat Cheese Tea Sandwich
wheat, dairy, goat cheese, fig, cucumber, arugula

Orange Marmalade Roll
wheat, dairy, eggs, yeast, orange extract & marmalade, orange zest

Lemon Curd
dairy, eggs, lemon

Chocolate Cheesecake
wheat, dairy, eggs, vanilla

Cranberry Pavlova
dairy, eggs, cranberries, honey, white vinegar, cornstarch, vanilla, spices

Chai Custard Ice Cream with Chocolate Spice Cookie
wheat, dairy, eggs, “Indian Assam” tea, vanilla, cloves, spices

A three-tiered tray with assorted finger foods on a wooden table set for tea, with vintage teacups, saucers, and a lace tablecloth in a cozy, warmly lit room.
A three-tiered tray holds assorted finger sandwiches, scones, pastries, and desserts. A cup of tea and more pastries sit on a floral-patterned tablecloth nearby. The setting is cozy and elegant.
A cozy tea setting with a tiered tray of pastries, teapots, teacups, and plates on a wooden table, surrounded by vintage furniture, blankets, and warm decorations in a softly lit room.
A simple brown fleur-de-lis symbol on a light gray background.

Prices and Menu Options

Ornate, symmetrical divider with loops and swirls in light brown, featuring small circular accents at each end, used for decorative separation in documents or invitations.

Prices listed are for the menu on this page. Subject to change without notice.

We are proud to pay our employees above minimum wage. No Tip is expected or required.

Regular Adult Menu
64.91 + Tax

Three-tiered tray of savories, breads, and sweets. Paired with three fine teas. Decaf options (less caffeine) and Herbal options (naturally caffeine-free) available for teas.

64.91 + Tax
Regular Child Menu
51.98 + Tax

(Ages 4 – 10; Children under 4 are not permitted) Abbreviated menu for smaller appetites. Paired with three fine, caffeine-free teas.

51.98 + Tax
Adult Double Savories, NO Sweets Menu
69.78 + Tax

Three-tiered tray of savories, breads, and an extra set of savories instead of the sweets. Sweets can be ordered in advance for an additional charge.

69.78 + Tax
Child Double Savories, NO Sweets Menu
51.98 + Tax

(Ages 4 – 10; Children under 4 are not permitted) Abbreviated menu for smaller appetites, in which the sweets are exchanged for an extra set of savories. Sweets can be ordered in advance for an additional charge.

51.98 + Tax
Nut-Free Menu Option
64.91 + Tax

Prepared in a kitchen where nuts are in use. Advance notice of 48 hours required. Not combinable with Vegetarian or Gluten-Free options. No substitutions.

64.91 + Tax
Vegetarian Menu Option
64.91 + Tax

Advance notice of 48 hours required. Not combinable with Nut-Free or Gluten-Free options. No substitutions.

64.91 + Tax
Adult Gluten-Free Menu
70.60 + Tax

Arrives on a separate three-tiered tray, especially for you. Prepared in a kitchen where gluten is in use. Advance notice of 48 hours required. Not combinable with Vegetarian or Nut-Free options. No substitutions.

70.60 + Tax
Child Gluten-Free Menu
57.67 + Tax

Prepared in a kitchen where gluten is in use. Advance notice of 48 hours required. Not combinable with Vegetarian or Nut-Free options. No substitutions.

57.67 + Tax

PLEASE CALL US FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Ornate, symmetrical divider with loops and swirls in light brown, featuring small circular accents at each end, used for decorative separation in documents or invitations.